That depends on your insurance company and agent. If you have a local agent, you should be able pick up your card in person. That’s one thing agencies do more than anything else – print out insurance cards for people like you and me. Thanks for the comment, Marilyn!

Thank you so much for this post.
I was so worried because I had been pulled over a couple nights ago for a burnt out tail light and when they asked me for my insurance card I only had my old one! I know I miss placed my new one and was so worried there would be a lengthy process to getting a new one. Although I do have one question, can you pick up your card in person?