Compare Rates From Top Providers
Save Up To 46% on Car Insurance
Enter Zip Code:

Cheapest Car Insurance in Ohio

Written by Todd Clay. Posted in Rates Last Updated: 11/08/2008

Looking for the cheapest auto insurance in Ohio?  Check out the 25 cheapest insurers from our independent research in the Buckeye State.

Crusin' for Cheap Car Insurance in Ohio?

Crusin' for Cheap Car Insurance in Ohio

Looking for cheapest car insurance in Ohio?

Getting quotes from 50+ car insurance carriers would be a waste of a good weekend.  But don’t worry.  We’ve laid the groundwork for you. Our sample rates from Ohio give you a good idea of what insurers charge their customers.  The list compiles 25 cheap car insurance companies.  Notice how I didn’t say ‘best’, I just said cheap.

Every driver is different.  What you see below is a sample of male and female drivers throughout the state, ages 19-70.  Quotes listed are for more than the minimum car insurance package required by law in Ohio.  In other words, if you get minimum liability limits from these companies, you might pay less money than listed below.

Prices listed are NOT the same as the price you will receive from the companies below. In addition, these are NOT actual quotes.  This list should serve as a general guide to help you shop for car insurance in Ohio.

Rank

Car Insurance Companies in Ohio

Average Premium

1

Kansas City Fire & Marine

$668.16

2

Selective of the Southeast

$709.20

3

Montgomery Ward

$709.64

4

Lightning Rod Mutual

$726.33

5

California Casualty Indemnity Exchange

$758.16

6

AMEX

$779.00

7

Royal

$819.24

8

Allstate Property and Casualty

$826.92

9

Travelers P&C

$830.52

10

USAA Casualty

$867.96

11

Travelers Casualty

$875.40

12

Atlantic Mutual

$883.24

13

Cincinnati

$885.72

14

Cincinnati Casualty

$885.72

15

GEICO General

$906.32

16

Government Employees

$906.32

17

State Farm Mutual

$921.96

18

Travelers Commercial

$929.76

19

Erie

$989.04

20

State Farm Fire & Casualty

$1,014.72

21

Halcyon

$1,044.36

22

Horace Mann Property Casualty

$1,091.08

23

PRUGEN

$1,098.65

24

Progressive Casualty

$1,127.80

25

Amica Mutual

$1,133.84

Rates published in April 2008.
All data is courtesy of the Ohio Department of Insurance.
For more information, view our Disclosure.

Tags:

Trackback from your site.

Todd Clay

Todd Clay is a former insurance agent with the largest insurance company in the United States. He earned his Bachelor’s from the University of Texas. He’s worked in several fields but has specialized in insurance, financial-related information, and technology. He blogs at Car Insurance Guidebook.

Connect with Tood on
Google+

Leave a comment

Overall Rating
Price
Service
Claims

Save Up To 46% on Car Insurance
Enter Zip Code: