Compare Rates From Top Providers
Save Up To 46% on Car Insurance
Enter Zip Code:

Best Car Insurance Companies Reviewed By You

Written by Michele Wilmonen. Posted in Research Last Updated: 02/23/2015

Reviews by current and former customers can help you find the best car insurance companies.

If you are in the market for new car insurance, finding the best car insurance company can be a daunting task. How do you know if you are selecting the right company to go with?

While there is no way to predict how your experience with any particular insurance company is going to go, you can learn from the experiences of other people. People that have taken the time to provide reviews of their experience with their current or former car insurance company just for people like you to read.

Best Car Insurance Companies by the Stars

We have been collecting car insurance company ratings from readers like you for many years now. So far we have quite the nice collection of companies that are still proudly holding on to their 5 stars and those that have yet to earn their first.

But because you are here to find out who the best car insurance company is, here are our companies that are proudly displaying 5 star reviews:

  • Allied
  • American National Insurance
  • Auto-Owners Insurance
  • Bear River Mutual Insurance
  • California Casualty
  • Cincinnati Insurance
  • Consumers Insurance USA
  • Eastwood Insurance
  • Elephant Auto Insurance
  • Frankenmuth Insurance
  • GMAC Insurance
  • Shelter Insurance
  • Vermont Mutual Insurance Group

Might Still Be the Best Car Insurance Companies

Because you can’t please everyone all of the time, we also have some pretty good car insurance companies that have 3-4 star ratings.  So don’t let the fact that these companies don’t have the perfect 5 stars prevent you from reading through the reviews or getting a quote from them.

  • 21st Century Insurance
  • AAA Insurance
  • AIG Insurance
  • Alfa Alliance Insurance
  • Allstate Insurance
  • American Family Insurance
  • Amica Insurance
  • Casualty Corporation of America, Inc.
  • Commerce Insurance
  • Direct General Insurance
  • Equity Insurance
  • Erie Insurance
  • Fred Loya Insurance
  • GEICO Insurance
  • Grange Insurance
  • Haulers Insurance
  • Imperial Fire and Casualty Insurance
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • Mercury Insurance
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Safety Insurance
  • State Farm Insurance
  • The General Insurance
  • Travelers Insurance
  • USAA Insurance

For more insurance reviews, or to add your own experience with your insurance company to our reviews, visit our Auto Insurance Reviews page.

Trackback from your site.

Michele Wilmonen

Michele’s first introduction to insurance was working for a major insurance company as a file clerk and a mailroom supervisor in a regional office. She learned insurance directly from underwriters and claims adjusters from questions and also watching them do their job. Since then, she’s earned a number of insurance certifications from the Insurance Institute of America and also a Bachelor’s degree from the University of Idaho. She blogs at Car Insurance Guidebook.

Leave a comment

Overall Rating

Save Up To 46% on Car Insurance
Enter Zip Code: